How many notches are too many? pt.2

Posted by Kathleen Fasanella on Jul 10, 2013 at 5:35 pm / Patterns / Trackback

In continuation of yesterday’s introduction, I think it is important to stress that too many notches is a cognitive shortcut. However unfair, one is going to presume a pattern such that we sampled was made by an inexperienced practitioner and will require closer scrutiny. What goes unsaid is that the more important issue of new patterns is that the seam lines weren’t walked because this isn’t something that is stressed in school. I went to a decent school but I didn’t learn how to walk my patterns until I started working. Production pattern making isn’t what people think; anyone can learn to do it (there is a whole chapter on it in my book). It is probably better described as pattern checking. There are related links at close.

The problem with doing an exercise like this is that you always walk the seam before you sew it -actually, it should have been done prior to cutting- so I walked just the princess seam -that being enough since this style was already a problem. Below is a double pane showing the results. On the left, the pieces are laid side by side and I think we can agree that the seam lengths look pretty good, so good one would be tempted to not even check it

tmn_princess_seamline_matching

On the right side of the pane you can see not checking would have been to one’s detriment because the seam is a full 1/4″ off; the center front is longer along the seam line. My my.

tmn_sewn_princess And in case you wonder, I can confirm that in spite of this being a two piece front, it is a flat piece with no shaping that has been cut down the middle so it is easy to overlay the two edges and get an accurate seam (as seen in the right pane above). As this is a child’s pattern, this isn’t as tragic as it would be for an adult. Still, I’ve often wondered why one bothered to split the piece if there was no shaping -unless the panels were different fabrications. Otherwise, it seems wasteful, extra costs to sew, extra costs to cut, extra costs to grade and bundle -what’s the point? But I digress.

At right is the result of the first seaming. As we discussed yesterday, the seam allowance notches along the vertical princess seam at the shoulder and waist are lost. Kinda. As I’ll show you, those notches -artifacts really- have the potential to create problems all their own. It’s no different than detritus in your shop or home. Leaving something laying out in the open isn’t hurting anything but the clutter is an eye sore and someone can trip and fall over it. I suppose you could think of it as 5S-ing your blueprints.

tmn_waist_seam_rigamaroleMoving along, one needs to add the lower waist segment, the first step being to ____ ___ ______. Yes, walk your pattern. Gold stars for everyone! And once we do this we see something a bit disconcerting. by this I mean that the waist seam of the upper bodice had allowance notches but the waist seam of the lower bodice does not. See what I mean by cognitive shortcut?

Doing this properly, you lay the seam lines together as they would lay when being sewn. In this image (click through, it’s not shown) you can see that the lower bodice is also 1/4″ too large to join the upper bodice.

tmn_shoulder_seamIn a production environment, people will give this a fair shake in that they’ll walk a seam or three but if every seam they’ve checked is a mis-match, they’ll throw in the towel. This pattern has other issues -too large seam allowances for one. Who uses 1/2″ seam allowance in a neckline?

Okay, so let us move on to the problems those useless notches cause. First up is the shoulder line (above right). How is one to sew this? Aligning to the shoulder seam notch stuck in the princess seam leads to a catty wonky seam so that is obviously not a solution; it must be angled which raises the spectre of Esther’s comment yesterday that excessive notching can lead to seam bursting (seam failure).

Below, we have a visual of the waist seam before sewing with a two-pane comparison of the sewn seam at upper left. The right side of the inset pane is a magnitude larger, sorry about that. I hope it isn’t too confusing but I did want to get a close up of the stitch line.

tmn_waist_seam

The ruler shows that the waist seam was sewn at 1/2″ as required but the seam is missing the mark of the intended waist seam allowance notches that were stuck into the princess line.

At right in the above photo, you can see the CF edge of the upper bodice waist seam is shaped rather oddly. The CF seam at the waist needs to be squared off a minimum of 1″ on either side of the overlap which is actually closer to 2″.

To me this says the pattern maker wasn’t sure what to do -and I feel for them because they have little guidance. It’s not like it was when we were coming up. Many of us had supervisors or other pattern makers on the job that we could ask (sometimes futilely but that’s another story). Anyway, the patternmaker remembers -correctly- from pattern class that a properly fitted bodice pattern actually curves up at the CF waist. However, this garment is not fitted, there is no curvature in the princess seam and the piece being flat, should not have a curve at the CF waist. Compounding the problem, this is for little kids. Little kids have bellies so if anything, the bottom of the CF upper bodice should be longer, curving down, not bowing up.

I suppose the above and what I’ll show next is beyond the scope of this post, not particularly dealing with notches but it does reinforce the cognitive shortcut that excessive notching is indicative of other problems (if it quacks like a duck, walks like a duck…) so it would be good to go out of your way to avoid being taken for a duck and refrain from being notch-happy.

tmn_hem_not_squared

The lower bodice looked off so I laid an L-square on it and this isn’t going to hang evenly horizontal at the center front hem. This would be okay if the style was meant to hike in front but it wasn’t intended to do that. The hiking at CF would be compounded by the horizontal seam at the waist. When you have a suit coat type front hem finish with facing and you want it straight on a large bellied body (also applies to expectant mothers), you have to add curvature and length at a horizontal waist seam if it is available.

In sum, this pattern is a train wreck. Now I’m going to tell you the rest of the story. This was a home sewing pattern. The designer didn’t want me to know she was using home patterns so she hired a design student to put it on oaktag, modifying the seams to 1/2″ (because that’s what “everybody” does now) and mark it properly or at least, as well as the student knew to do (she did forget armhole notches for sure). The student wasn’t supposed to make pattern corrections -who knows if she could have, it would have been a lot of work and require advanced skills. All told, this was not fair to the student so don’t do this to an intern if you have one. Someone else might not have known the back story and would have thought the student was grossly incompetent. And not that the designer told me, I figured it out.

Related:
Production pattern making class
Tip for checking your patterns
How on earth do you use oak tag to MAKE patterns?
Paper patterns, soft or hard?
How to walk a pattern (video)
How to walk a pattern pt.2
Poka Yoke pattern making
How to walk a collar

8 Responses to “How many notches are too many? pt.2”

Comments RSS feed

Quincunx
July 10th, 2013
7:10 PM

. . .what a cruddy thing to do to an intern (or a student).

Natasha E
July 10th, 2013
10:05 PM

I’ve studied patternmaking at two institutions one public one private and I have a theory. I’ve very type A. I hate losing points when I could have a perfect score. Not having notches where you should them equals points off. Two many you’ll get a pass, sometimes a light scolding or perhaps be forced to recut (this never happened) but you’d still get all your points because you met all the requirements.

In first school I studied at you got judged on the final product though you had to submit patterns of course. So if you were good at sewing and MAKING things fit together and you have a reputation for putting out good work the instructor wouldn’t walk it and you’d get A++. At the other (private) school things had to walk ok but things were graded on a weekly basis so mistakes were caught earlier and corrected and if it overall ok you’d still get an A+

So I think its not because its not being taught but because certain instructors grading habits make the student (me) feel like they were doing A ok.

Patricia
July 11th, 2013
10:42 AM

Thank you so much Kathleen. Your explanation is very clear and detailed, as always.
I had different pattern teachers in school and noticed that the ones who were in their late 50’s, 60’s were more strict and walked the seam lines… as stupid students, we hated doing it. The younger teacher (early 40’s) never picked on this detail, I can not even remember if she ever taught it in class.

Mary L
July 11th, 2013
12:26 PM

You would have a field day with India patterns Kathleen! They are not notched at all and nothing is squared.

Kathleen
July 11th, 2013
12:38 PM

Patricia: I don’t like doing it on the job either but if I didn’t, my boss would find it and I’d feel foolish. Working for myself I do it because I’d be mortified if a customer’s contractor found errors.

Mary: Tip of the iceberg… I don’t know what it is but a culture of reproducibility seems to be absent there. As such, none of the best practices and hallmarks are employed. That said, I can’t begin to tell you how many pitches I get to subcontract my pattern services there.

Bernadette
July 11th, 2013
5:41 PM

Kathleen, luckily for me, Fran Potter was teaching pattermaking at El Centro when I was there.
Walking was mandatory! The students who didn’t were always busted…

Adrienne Gonzales
July 12th, 2013
7:04 PM

Perhaps I shouldn’t reveal but I don’t have a pattern notcher yet so I cut them by hand. Obviously it’s very tedious and they have to be cut perfectly so I am very discerning about placement and usage.

A notcher is on my list of things to get soon, I promise :)

JustGail
July 15th, 2013
6:49 AM

the designer had a student/intern copy a home sewing pattern… so those times that I’ve sewn something up from a commercial pattern and things didn’t line up after the seams were sewin – it wasn’t *always* my fault?!?! Well. Huh. I think I’m happysad on this. Happy because it’s not always me, sad because I feel…I don’t want to say stupid, but I’m not sure how else to put it, for assuming the pattern is right. I’ll have to add “walk the pattern before sewing” to my list of pre-sewing steps, along with pretreat the fabric. Are there any seams that are more likely to have issues? Like princess seams, arm scye, etc?).

Leave a Reply

Archives

Categories

The Entrepreneur's Guide to Sewn Product Manufacturing

Often described as the garment industry “blue book”, the most highly rated book in the business is guaranteed to get you off to a solid start or your money back. Many service providers require you read this before they’ll work with you. Learn more »

Subscription Options

RSS Feed Google Reader My Yahoo My MSN Technorati

Subscribe by email: