How to hire a pattern maker pt.47

Posted by Kathleen Fasanella on Feb 6, 2008 at 1:32 pm / Newbies, Patterns, Process Reviews, Rants, Sourcing / Trackback

MC writes:

I am having great difficulty figuring out the best possible way to handle the following situation. I hired a freelance pattern maker to develop a total of five patterns (we are doing women’s contemporary sportswear). For four of them, we had provided an original sample with our exact fit and measurements from which to start. Starting off, we gave her one pattern and we felt it was good enough to give her the other four sketches and samples.

We are unhappy with the results so far and don’t think we’re getting good value. She charges $85 an hour (which I felt was warranted with her 35 years experience and good first sample). At this point we have shelled out $3,000.00 to her and only one of the five samples is satisfactory. We have gone through 2 fittings now, and from the first fitting to the second, there were no visible changes in the sample. Two pant styles were still swimming on our fit model on the second fitting. None of the corrections were made.

Her excuse is that she “hasn’t had time to oversee her assistants”. She puts everything on her assistants, yells at them in our fittings for not overseeing the sewers or making correct adjustments ….but aren’t we paying for her to do our patterns or at least oversee most of the process? And she always has an excuse as to why she needs an extra week or more time. So, we have paid her $3,000.00 so far, and now she has invoiced us for another $1000.00 for pattern corrections.

I have had countless conversations with this woman regarding our dissatisfaction with her work, but she keeps saying that we are paying for her time and that pattern makers are underpaid etc. I don’t feel we should have to pay another $1000.00 when there were no visible changes in the fit of our garments from one fitting to the next, but I also want to be fair and do the right thing. If you have any advice, it would be greatly appreciated.


~sigh~
Before I start, I spoke with MC by phone for a few more details. Regarding this email, let’s deal with things in order, first her hourly. You live in California in a high rent district. $85 an hour for someone with 35 years experience isn’t out of line. Typical rates across the country are $35 (midwest) to $100 (NY). I charge $50 (25+yrs exp). My friend Sally (35 years exp) charges $60 but she lives in a relatively low rent area (Albuquerque). Patternworks Inc in LA has a sterling reputation and I think their prices are competitive for that market. By phone, I could tell you were not trying to be a budget buster and that you were willing to pay competitive rates for productive results.

By phone, we discussed the fit meetings of which three elements were outstanding.

  1. There was no difference in samples between fittings.
  2. She berates her staff in your presence. Ouch.
  3. She runs up time on the clock, charging hourly.

About differences between samples and having fit meetings. Fit meetings can be exciting; it’s the first time you get to see your idea on a living breathing body so your excitement can run away with you. This is business. You must get out a sheet of paper and take notes, one sheet per style (this is in the book). Bring a polaroid or digital camera to take photos for later comparison. The pattern must be in the room for examination; bring your own tape measure. Make written notes of changes you want. The pattern maker should be taking notes too. Get copies of them! Make sure your notes match. If need be, make copies of yours and have them initial them. Use the Input Control Form on page 80 of my book. There are boxes to check for approval or progress. Everyone should initial these so you know you’re in agreement as to how things should proceed. It sounds like you may have been a victim of hangar fix, a pattern correction strategy of questionable integrity.

In a fit meeting, don’t be afraid to approach the pattern. If you don’t like the length of something, check the pattern and the garment. Make note of these measures. Ditto for girth changes. This way you’ll have a point of comparison in subsequent fittings. If you wanted the waist reduced by an inch and a comparison to the second sample is the same, you shouldn’t pay for pattern corrections or the sample -unless this is a minor nuance, they admit the oversight and had rendered other changes in addition to this one. Don’t be intimidated. If I have a customer check a pattern in my presence, I’m not offended. If anything, I’m reassured. If they’re doing it wrong, I’m thrilled to have the opportunity for a teaching moment. If they’re doing it really wrong, I may giggle and want to hug them but I couldn’t be more pleased that you’re taking an interest in my work and trying to understand it (a big compliment). The more you know about how patterns work, the more confidence I’m going to have in your ability to communicate changes by phone. No good pattern maker should be upset if you try to get up close and personal with the pattern. It is your property.

Berating staff in your presence. For this reason alone, you can’t do business with this person anymore. Your work is being used as a vehicle to abuse other people. Worse, you don’t know what she’s saying about you to her staff behind your back. Everything that’s wrong, she’ll blame on you, that you’re being unreasonable (and maybe you are but that’s beside the point; it’d be unprofessional of her to say so). Ever wonder why people won’t look you in the eye or glare at you? How is her staff going to care about doing your work well if she’s told them you’re an awful customer? This is very unprofessional and very sad. It breaks my heart. My first reaction is to want to open my fat mouth and register disapproval while it’s happening but I usually just leave and never come back.

A word to designers with pattern makers on staff. Be wary, monitor the ambiance in your work room. Some designers think their pattern makers are just great (!) but they’re monsters behind your back. For what it’s worth, the tyrants aren’t all that great at pattern work either although they’re good at saying others are to blame for poor results (hint). If a pattern maker is good, they don’t need to berate people to get them to perform. I cannot abide a petty tyrant. Besides, the power is in the inverse. Just as a pattern maker can destroy the career of a designer who gets on the wrong side of them, so can a sample maker make life very difficult for a pattern maker. You bake them cookies and babysit their kids, you don’t yell at them. If their work is lacking, a pattern maker should train or help them to resolve problems. If it can’t be sewn, it’s rarely the sample makers fault -once all other avenues have been exhausted.

The issue of running up the clock can be a case of “he said, she said” but it doesn’t take three hours to fit five garments. That’s ludicrous. When I’ve had people do that to me, I start tracking time and make it obvious. Usually that stops it. As I explained by phone, it’s not so much that she personally spends all that time on you, it’s how efficacious the time is being spent by one of her employees. Regardless of who’s involved and who’s time you’re paying for, it shouldn’t be wasted. She is responsible for all time charged no matter who’s doing the work.

About charges in general. In the old days, pattern makers used to charge by the pattern (prices listed pg 70). Some still do it like this. For changes beyond what was contracted, fees are charged hourly but it’s rarely inordinate. These days, with so many people getting into the business without grounding, more are charging hourly to cover talk time. The sum of which remains that I have a hard time believing it cost $4,000 for five samples and patterns that don’t work. As a point of comparison, Patternworks once mentioned they charged $7,000 -a hefty amount- but it was for 45 styles which ended up being quite a bargain. The most complicated design I can think of off hand, say one of those parrot jackets, might be $1,000 all told but you’re doing basic women’s sportswear, not a multi-piece lined leather jacket with a high degree of difficulty and demand of execution.

The sad fact remains, there are people out there who know there’s tons of people hot on becoming designers and they don’t have a problem taking advantage of you. I regret that. All I can do is hope people will make use of the resources I provide to counteract it.

One last thing…MC mentions this pattern maker’s nails are always immaculately polished and her hair is impeccably coiffed and styled. That’s usually a bad sign. Pattern makers are engineers and fit the profile. Don’t hire someone who fits the image of what you want your customer to be like or who mirrors your personal grooming habits. It usually ends poorly.

Related:
How to hire a pattern maker pt.46
How to hire a pattern maker pt.47
How to hire a pattern maker pt. 48

14 Responses to “How to hire a pattern maker pt.47”

Comments RSS feed

Vesta
February 6th, 2008
3:08 PM

All of the pattern makers I have worked with (btw, most of whom were recommended by contractors) charge by the pattern piece. That’s in California and Texas.

What a total bummer.

Lisa thedomesticdiva
February 7th, 2008
3:52 AM

How sad! This is the stuff that makes me nervous as I’m currently looking for a patternmaker in NYC (preferrably Brooklyn) for my children’s line.

You don’t know who to trust. But thanks for the guidelines (and the info in the book)–hopefully I won’t be taken to the cleaners…LOL!

With friendship,
Lisa

Amy
February 7th, 2008
11:00 AM

I recommend researching apparel manufacturers in the area–if you’re lucky enough to have them–and try to pirate a working pattern maker to do some moonlighting for you. Charging 1000$ for pattern revisions is criminal–they should have been right to begin with.

Lisa Bloodgood in Portland
February 7th, 2008
12:05 PM

I’m not a pattern maker. I have taken pattern making classes and I do know how to make some patterns. How outrageous that the pants weren’t even taken in and she’s trying to charge for that! Ugh!

This reminds me of the scene in the Firefly episode where the guy who was dueling with Mal tried to say he’s mess Inara up enough that she couldn’t ever work again but she said that he now gets a black mark in the client registry and no companion will ever be with him again.

Colleen
February 7th, 2008
7:46 PM

Do you have a paper trail? If a fit sample is submitted that doesn’t meet spec (within tolerance), I wouldn’t fit it (or pay for it). It’s not what you ordered!
All fit comments should be documented, any measurement changes updated on the spec and a copy given to the patternmaker. The patternmaker should make the changes you requested. She should measure the next fit sample to insure it meets spec, review it on a dress form and then, only if it’s within spec and fit/quality look good, submit to you.
When you receive the fit sample, you should measure it (compare to the patternmaker’s measurements) and evaluate the fit/quality. Begin recording fit notes with your preliminary findings. Start the fitting by calling out areas that don’t meet spec (but are within tolerance), fit/quality issues….
I’m curious, are the samples being made in production quality fabric? Are they submitting them in Black (which hides a lot of fit problems)?
Several years ago, I worked for a company that had sales exceeding a billion dollars; been in business since 1920 something. One of the Directors hired a freelance patternmaker out of N.Y. She charged $75 per fit comment and an additional $75 per sketch (no actual patterns, believe it or not). Her work was very poor quality. One of her sketches was a squiggly, hand drawn belt with 1″ added to the length. When I saw that, I had to laugh! Later, the NY based fit model said that this “patternmaker” had her assistants (FIT students)conduct the fit sessions, write the comments and draw the sketches; the patternmaker was seldom in the room! So, MC, it happens to established companies, too!
Do you have a contract with her? I recently learned from hiring an architect that, although he charges an hourly rate, once the scope of the project is agreed upon, there is a “not to exceed” price. Your patternmaker should have been able to estimate the cost of developing the five patterns and been able to give you a “not to exceed” price.
I hope my comments are helpful, not just long winded!

Tracey Valliere-Evans
February 9th, 2008
3:31 AM

Unreal & so annoyingly sad, never mind bad-for-business. At the end of the day it is her (pattern-cutting) business, & the ball lands in her court if things have not been done right; I would walk away & use someone else, frustrating I know, but surely carrying on with this company would be business-suicide! Is her ’35’ years of experience actually in pattern-cutting herself…or simply having a business, offering this as a service with her staff doing it?? I do think, if I were doing business with someone & they put their staff down/shouted at them/blamed them for errors, that I would be greatly put off doing any further business with them; it would be embarrassing. I wish MC much more success with her next pattern-cutter, & thanks for the tip on appearances Kathleen!

PS We have a real shortage of (good) pattern-cutters here & so sadly we have had a few experiences of patterns that don’t work but thankfully never to this cost – thanks for all your info Kathleen!

Saar Machtinger
February 12th, 2008
11:29 PM

Hi,

As I represent OptiTex I can say that we also offer some pattern making services. This is done through our HQ office.

We charge by the style, and we can also provide to you with a 3D simulation of the finsihed product. This gives you an option to view the final product before you even order the fabric or have made a muslin.

I truly think that charging by the hour is not the common thing today.

Saar

Timo Rissanen
February 14th, 2008
10:56 PM

I’m catching up; just a quick, but big, thanks for a fantastic post as well as comments!

Kate
August 5th, 2008
2:19 PM

I am developing a line of children’s clothing for children that are ill. As I am “just” a seamstress I am finding it difficult to explain satisfactorily what I am seeking. I have had several models sent back to me that are exactly like what I sent them. I wonder what I would get if I just drew the garment on paper. I guess I expected them to offer ideas on how to make the garment so that it would save fabric by eliminating a seam here or there. Do I need to hire someone else to fine tune my idea first? Any ideas would be greatfully appreciated. Thanks, Kate

Trisha
March 27th, 2011
6:50 PM

We are trying to find any advice we can get. Being in LA we have tried employing Patternworks for pattern making services and the owner refused to sign an NDA. Instead we suggested a letter of understanding. I wrote a very simple paragraph long letter stating that the products they will produce are the property of my company and they (patterworks) promises not to use the products created for our company to compete. They refused to sign that as well stating it was too “vague. “

Kathleen
April 30th, 2011
9:47 AM

We are trying to find any advice we can get. Being in LA we have tried employing Patternworks for pattern making services and the owner refused to sign an NDA.

I surmise the advice you seek is how to get PatternWorks to sign an NDA because advice on hiring a pattern maker generally and specifically is widespread if not redundant on this site.

I can’t tell you how to get PW to sign your NDA because I won’t sign them either (I’m also a service provider). You can read on this site why not signing an NDA is a greater indicator of integrity than the reverse. I only speak for myself but my code of professional conduct exceeds that of an NDA so I wouldn’t sign an inferior contract either.

The other thing is, the increasing interest in NDAs comes from only one segment of the market, specifically those entering the business. Since the majority of our customers are long term, well established and don’t need contracts to insure our discretion, we would only need to hire an IP attorney for your job. Meaning, the cost of services provided to you would be dramatically higher because IP attorneys cost $450 an hour. As a practical matter tho, we’d just turn it down because the hassle of finding and meeting with an attorney in addition to the time spent with you in negotiating the matter, would exceed any time we have available because our other customers keep us busy.

The only advice I can offer is to look for another service that is aligned to that which you perceive to be your priorities and I wish you well as you move forward.

Nelly
August 24th, 2011
11:42 AM

I’m a freelance patternmaker located in LA. It’s hard to tried people but is our responsibility to keep our client satisfied with our work. I charge per style and the package I offer. I never charge per adjustments from first fitting. I really don’t know if is not okay but I really sure that If I want to receive my payment I need to do a good job.

ANN
January 10th, 2012
4:46 PM

I am a fashion designer and also a patternmaker. I freelance my patternmaking services in NYC.
I don’t understand the diva-esque mentality with the fashion folks in NY, it is almost like working in hell. I have seen my fair share of yelling that goes on at fittings (not to me). The designers/buyers are cut of the same fabric as anyone else, most of the time I find they do not have common sense which is essential along with technical knowledge in corrections.

It is just clothes folks… get a reality check!!

ANN
January 10th, 2012
9:24 PM

I went for an interview a couple of days ago at XXX. Funny thing is while the HR lady and the Director of Tech Design were telling me to have a positive attitude and get along with co-workers, they themselves could not help arguing right in front of me during the interview.

Leave a Reply

Archives

Categories

The Entrepreneur's Guide to Sewn Product Manufacturing

Often described as the garment industry “blue book”, the most highly rated book in the business is guaranteed to get you off to a solid start or your money back. Many service providers require you read this before they’ll work with you. Learn more »

Subscription Options

RSS Feed Google Reader My Yahoo My MSN Technorati

Subscribe by email: